I think I’m the only person who really believes in second chances. I’m that kind of hopeless romantic who would stand out in the rain for someone, waiting while I get so drenched that pneumonia would nestle down deep in my lungs. I’d run after someone until my legs gave out and I’d have to crawl forward to latch onto the person’s ankle just to stop them from leaving. I am the kind of girl who has so much faith that I’d write a love letter, give it to the guy, have him reject me, and then still hold out for him because I believe there’s still a chance with him.
It was a Friday night, my parents were out at a get-together across town, and although I had been invited to go with them, I stuck with my plan of watching a horror movie marathon. However, I discovered I was out of anything to eat. I was going to settle for nothing, except then I realized that the kid next door were having a house party, and I’d heard about it earlier that week that there were kids from all over town… especially from up the block.
I tried to swallow the curiosity that rose. I knew damn well who lived up the block. An image popped into my head of myself leaning casually against the wall of a hazy living room. He would come over to me.
“Wow, Lucy, I didn’t expect to see you here,” he’d say.
“Well,” I’d flip my hair over my shoulder in a totally attractive way, “It’s only my first social event of the night.”
Okay, ew, maybe I wouldn’t say something as stupid as that. But the fantasy was the push I needed. I threw on a hoodie over my clothes, laced up my sneakers, and hopped over the wooden fence into the next yard. If anybody asked, I was there for chips.
For a house party, they didn’t have much food, so my lame excuse backfired. They also barely had any music playing. It seemed like the only thing anyone wanted to do there was get wasted and have their buddy take a picture of the vomit. I thought this was kind of pointless, because you could do that by yourself. I guess spending your Friday night upchucking bits of your semi-destroyed liver beat being chipless during a movie marathon. As soon as I got in there, some guy staggered past and spilled his drink all over me, prompting the thought that maybe I should have just stayed in my house.
So there I was, standing alone in the middle of a dimly lit kitchen, surrounded by idiots getting wasted on watery booze, holding my damp sweatshirt in my hands, thinking my night probably couldn’t get any worse, when I looked through the doorway into the living room and caught sight of him.
Harvey Mitchells was leaning back against the wall, arms crossed over his chest like he was cool or something, nodding at some girl and her stupid tube top that barely covered her chest. She had a red solo cup in her manicured grasp, and I could hear how her words tilted and slid together as she talked, batting her eyelashes so hard I thought she was going to pass out. I watched as she placed her hand on Harvey’s chest. He slid his hands around her waist.
All of a sudden I felt as woozy as the kid next to me. Even though I told myself I was over Harvey. Even though I lied to myself enough times that I didn’t care about what he did. Even though I’d been preparing myself to see him with another girl, I wasn’t ready. Of all the horror movies I had planned to see, I never thought it would be this.
And I could have made it to the front door unseen, if Harvey hadn’t looked over that girl’s head and made eye contact with me. When I remembered how to breathe, I practically sprinted out the front door.
I didn’t expect him to follow me.
“Lucy! Wait up!”
I skidded to a stop halfway across the driveway, cursing my stupid feet, cursing him, cursing everyone in the existence of the universe who ever thought it was a good idea to write someone a love letter. Turning over my shoulder, I saw him standing there, the porch light stretching out our shadows. The November evening had a chill that tasted like winter, dead leaves skittered past my Converse. I shivered in my tee shirt and thin sweatpants.
Harvey walked forward and stopped in front of me. I could see now he was wearing faded jeans and a long sleeve gray shirt.
I said the first thing that crossed my mind, hell, the only thing that was on my mind. “You and her?”
He shoved his hands into his pockets. “Yeah.”
I nodded, but in my head my conscience was screaming its little imaginary lungs out for me to get out of there before I embarrassed myself. Like I hadn’t done enough of that already.
A funny little smile pulled at his lips, “How am I supposed to give you space when you’re everywhere I turn?” He said it like a joke, trying to ease the tension, but it really just made things suck even more.
Because that’s what he had said after he read my letter. He would give me space. Things would return back to normal between us. We would go back to being friends, or whatever that meant.
“Maybe you should start by not going to parties next door to me,” I managed to say.
He tilted his head at me, “Why were you in there, anyway? It’s not really like you to go to these things.”
“Chips,” I blurted, and then immediately wanted to kick myself.
Harvey squinted in confusion.
I stammered onward, “I mean— not chips—I mean I didn’t have any chips at my house… and… “ I couldn’t hide the truth any longer from him, “I just… I wanted to see if you… I heard you were going to be there and I wanted to see you.”
“Oh,” Harvey said. The syllable hung in the air between us.
“Even though I already wrote you a love letter,” I explained, and he stiffened at the mention of it, “Even though I’ve already admitted that I like you… I still have feelings for you. I guess I just thought you’d be here and that maybe… “
Harvey rocked on his heels and dipped his head at the ground. “What do you want me to say, Lucy?”
In my head I had it all planned out: Harvey Mitchells would tell me after two months that he loved me, he had just been afraid to say it. He would say he doesn’t deserve me, but he cares about me enough to try. He would kiss me. We would go watch that movie marathon.
But that wasn’t it.
All this time I’d been waiting for him to take that chance, and the realization struck me in the chest that it wasn’t him that wanted it, it was me. I’d just been trying to find some kind of second meaning between all of his rejections, when in reality there was nothing between his words but the truth. He didn’t like me. He wasn’t going to turn around and pronounce his love for me. And if I didn’t stop lying to myself, I was just going to keep on being miserable.
“I don’t know,” I whimpered.
We stood there as the crinkled leaves rushed past our feet, and someone started to blast Billy Joel and down the street a dog barked; and I understood that somewhere between the lines of that letter, our friendship had ended. It was nobody’s fault, but I knew, as Harvey shrugged, that if someone asked me to make a list of things I wanted in my life, he would not be the first. And whatever happened between him and that other girl didn’t matter, because I didn’t want to be with him anymore.
Sometimes the choices we make really suck, and the way the universe rotates is out of control, and there’s nowhere else to go but forward.
I took a deep breath, “I’ll see you Monday, Harvey.”
I left him there, walked the short distance to my house and sat on my front steps. Leaned my elbows on my knees and rested my chin there.
It was a nice night, there were gauzey clouds drifting against the first stars in the sky. I sat out there until my parents came home.